NBA’s biggest trade requests offer a reminder: Sometimes, keeping the star pays off

Kyrie Irving, Cavaliers, Cavs, NBA
NBAE via Getty

An unhappy superstar wants out. The rumors start flying. Everybody starts putting together trade packages.

Then comes the assumption that the team has no choice. Better move him before things get worse.

Well, NBA history offers a few reasons to take a breath.

Frank Urbina of HoopsHype⁠ ranked the 27 most important trade requests in league history, weighing both the players involved and what happened afterward. It’s a worthwhile trip through decades of basketball drama, with one particularly interesting wrinkle.

Four of his top five requests didn’t result in a trade.

Those players stayed put and won championships. Sometimes multiple championships. That doesn’t mean every fractured relationship can be repaired. It does mean a trade request and a departure aren’t always the same thing.

Kareem tops the list

Urbina placed Kareem Abdul-Jabbar’s 1974 request atop the rankings, and the case is pretty strong.

The Bucks eventually sent Abdul-Jabbar to the Lakers in 1975. He went on to win five championships and three MVP awards with Los Angeles, becoming a cornerstone of one of basketball’s great dynasties.

As HoopsHype recounts, Abdul-Jabbar’s desire to leave centered on his preference for a different city and cultural environment. Milwaukee was losing a franchise player without an obvious basketball problem it could fix.

That’s the difficult part for a front office. Sometimes, building a good team isn’t enough to keep its best player.

The Lakers, obviously, were happy to benefit.

The requests that went nowhere

Magic Johnson checks in at No. 2 for his 1981 request, which followed frustration with coach Paul Westhead’s offense.

Johnson stayed. Westhead didn’t.

Pat Riley ultimately took over, and the Lakers won the championship that season. Johnson won four more titles after making that request, all with the team he had wanted to leave.

Urbina ranks Shaquille O’Neal’s dispute during the 2000-01 season third. O’Neal expressed a desire to be traded amid his frustrations with the offense and Kobe Bryant, but general manager Mitch Kupchak treated it as something the Lakers could resolve.

They did enough resolving to finish their three-peat.

Hakeem Olajuwon is fourth for his 1992 request following a bitter disagreement with Rockets management over his injured hamstring. Houston kept him and eventually won consecutive championships in 1994 and 1995.

Then comes Bryant at No. 5.

His 2007 request was public and emphatic. The Lakers nevertheless held onto him, eventually winning championships in 2009 and 2010.

Boy, imagine those teams explaining years later that they had traded their franchise player because the situation had become uncomfortable.

There’s a difference between an uncomfortable situation and an unfixable one. Identifying which one you have is the job.

Cavs fans know the other side

Kyrie Irving’s 2017 request ranks 17th on HoopsHype’s list, though it probably feels considerably bigger around Northeast Ohio.

The Cavs had reached three consecutive Finals and won the 2016 championship. This wasn’t a star looking to escape an endless rebuild.

It was a championship partnership breaking apart.

Irving went to the Celtics for a package built around Isaiah Thomas, Jae Crowder and the Nets’ 2018 first-round pick. Whatever anyone thought of the return, replacing Irving’s shot creation alongside LeBron James was a different matter.

That’s another lesson from these situations. Acquiring assets and replacing a star’s actual basketball value are two separate assignments.

Sometimes, the gamble delivers

Of course, the team acquiring the unhappy star can change its own history.

Kawhi Leonard’s 2018 request ranks eighth. The Raptors took their chance despite having no assurance of a lengthy partnership and won the 2019 championship.

Shaq’s eventual Lakers exit in 2004 ranks seventh. He helped the Heat win their first title in 2006, while Lamar Odom, part of the return, later helped the Lakers win two more.

Urbina’s full ranking makes clear that player-driven exits were around long before social media or today’s debates about player empowerment.

The harder question has always been what comes next. Sometimes, you make the trade and win a championship. Sometimes, you win one because you didn’t.

Looking for the latest NBA Insider News & Rumors?

Be sure to follow Hoops Wire on TWITTER and FACEBOOK for breaking NBA News and Rumors for all 30 teams!

LEAVE A REPLY